|
Malaysia Real Estate Malaysia Real Estate Portal
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Cannot Tahan
Joined: 27 Jul 2009 Posts: 291
|
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 7:43 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| king4891 wrote: | | Cannot Tahan wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | Cannot Tahan wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | lueng1,
What do think of this estimation of profit for 1120 Park Avenue base on your experience? Is it too low or too high?
My own perception:
Type L total units: 34 x 5 = 170 units.
Phase 1 Type L price: RM250k
Estimated Phase 2 Type L price: RM275k
After completion: RM305k (Consider low estimated appreciation, Bandar Puteri Klang also can appreciate 30k when completion)
Your actual purchase price RM250k - (250k * 0.075 = RM18750) = RM231250 - 20k (estimated interest save for first 3 years) + 3k (Lawyer Fees) + RM300 = RM214,550. (Take MLTA).
Phase 1 Net Profit: Selling 305k - RM214,550 = RM90,450.
Phase 2 Net Profit: RM65,450. |
Alamak, confirm u must be very young and not sold any property b4.
Your calcualtion is "Gross Profit" lah,
There are more things to deduct for NET PROFIT
Aiyoyo, no wonder 1120 can "appear" to be successful at this stage...
I hope this project never fail, otherwise must be very impactful yo your financial planning.... |
Yes I'm younger than you. But income more than you. |
Wah congrate x 100000000000m,
I never doubt it, coz ALL LAND belong to "KING" under NLC, HAHAHA
Hope u understand what NLC is, HEHEHE |
I'm doubting why you need here to fulfill your critics satisfaction. You really is a weird person I never met before. God bless you. |
Young rich King, you edited the Net profit calculation already, dun u want to deduct 2% Agent fee, transfer fee, R & R... as well,
dun learn only half, learn more |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cannot Tahan
Joined: 27 Jul 2009 Posts: 291
|
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 7:49 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| king4891 wrote: | | Cannot Tahan wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | Cannot Tahan wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | lueng1,
What do think of this estimation of profit for 1120 Park Avenue base on your experience? Is it too low or too high?
My own perception:
Type L total units: 34 x 5 = 170 units.
Phase 1 Type L price: RM250k
Estimated Phase 2 Type L price: RM275k
After completion: RM305k (Consider low estimated appreciation, Bandar Puteri Klang also can appreciate 30k when completion)
Your actual purchase price RM250k - (250k * 0.075 = RM18750) = RM231250 - 20k (estimated interest save for first 3 years) + 3k (Lawyer Fees) + RM300 = RM214,550. (Take MLTA).
Phase 1 Net Profit: Selling 305k - RM214,550 = RM90,450.
Phase 2 Net Profit: RM65,450. |
Alamak, confirm u must be very young and not sold any property b4.
Your calcualtion is "Gross Profit" lah,
There are more things to deduct for NET PROFIT
Aiyoyo, no wonder 1120 can "appear" to be successful at this stage...
I hope this project never fail, otherwise must be very impactful yo your financial planning.... |
Yes I'm younger than you. But income more than you. |
Wah congrate x 100000000000m,
I never doubt it, coz ALL LAND belong to "KING" under NLC, HAHAHA
Hope u understand what NLC is, HEHEHE |
I'm doubting why you need here to fulfill your critics satisfaction. You really is a weird person I never met before. God bless you. |
Walaueh, God also keluar meh? Maybe 1 role of 1120 can be transformed into a temple, HEHEHE
Young rich King, you edited the Net profit calculation already, dun u want to deduct 2% Agent fee, transfer fee, R & R... as well,
dun learn only half, learn more. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
patricktoh187
Joined: 01 Aug 2009 Posts: 25 Location: Kuala Lumpur
|
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 10:59 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 11:37 pm Post subject: |
|
|
 _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain
Last edited by Daryl Teo on Thu Dec 24, 2009 11:42 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 11:41 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 11:50 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ysmn wrote: | | I'm contemplating turning this thread into a script for a skit. Wonder if the webmeister owns the content. |
Think it would do very well in the art film circuit with CGI hamsters as actors running inside their little treadmills til they keel over!  _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
tkk
Joined: 19 Sep 2006 Posts: 100 Location: PJ
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 10:30 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! _________________ best regard,
tkk |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
cblee
Joined: 31 Oct 2005 Posts: 219
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 10:42 am Post subject: |
|
|
| tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! |
Bravo . MCHNY |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 11:04 am Post subject: |
|
|
| tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! |
Agree with u that comparisons should only be made within its specific classes as no 2 projects are alike even when proximate to each other, even from just across the road. Earlier i was just illustrating from Patrick's experience that projects could also go south for buyers, it's always good to get into something with your eyes wide open. Sometimes when we get into a buying frenzy we blindside ourselves to the obvious shortcomings or risks.
Btw i've heard time & again reference being made to Sri Manja as benchmarks for price appreciation for this project. I think that's flawed, as going by your same analogy that even within classes there're product & demographical differentiations. Sri Manja if u've noticed is predominantly chinese, with commercials that're thriving well there, but if u were to drive further away into PJS u would notice the changing landscape of the area, the quality of businesses & tenants deteriorates & the demographics changes, with more perceptibly lower income demographics of indians & malays housed in council flats & low costs houses, which i also understand is the same landscape PA1120 is also situated in. This would eventually have a bearing on its caps as it'll be a key issue by which secondary buyers evaluate its desirability affecting its price.
But having said that, i've also purchased a property from a not so reputable developer in a not so desirable area & thru sheer luck have enjoyed great yields & price caps. It was a dsl link 18'x65' in Bandar Baru Ampang by Talam, purchased in the late 90s for just below 100k, leasehold. Tenant has been paying 850k per month & market value now is min 250k to 280k. Key difference is the area is largely chinese & near to KL.
Cheers! MERRY X'MAS to all!  _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
tkk
Joined: 19 Sep 2006 Posts: 100 Location: PJ
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 11:12 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Daryl Teo wrote: | | tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! |
Agree with u that comparisons should only be made within its specific classes as no 2 projects are alike even when proximate to each other, even from just across the road. Earlier i was just illustrating from Patrick's experience that projects could also go south for buyers, it's always good to get into something with your eyes wide open. Sometimes when we get into a buying frenzy we blindside ourselves to the obvious shortcomings or risks.
Btw i've heard time & again reference being made to Sri Manja as benchmarks for price appreciation for this project. I think that's flawed, as going by your same analogy that even within classes there're product & demographical differentiations. Sri Manja if u've noticed is predominantly chinese & its commercials there have thrived well, but if u were to drive further away into PJS u would notice the changing landscape of the area, the quality of businesses & tenants deteriorates & the demographics changes, with more indians & malays housed in council flats & low costs houses, which i also understand is the same landscape PA1120 is also situated in. This would eventually have a bearing on its caps as it'll be a key issue by which secondary buyers evaluate its desirability affecting its price.
But having said that, i've also purchased a property from a not so reputable developer in a not so desirable area & thru sheer luck have enjoyed great yields & price caps. It was a dsl link 18'x65' in Bandar Baru Ampang by Talam, purchased in the late 90s for just below 100k, leasehold. Tenant has been paying 850k per month & market value now is min 250k to 280k. Key difference is the area is largely chinese & near to KL.
Cheers! MERRY X'MAS to all!  |
Hi Daryl,
I'm fully agreed with you... dun forget you are getting the key soon for sierra residency puchong!!! the appreciation is quick alot also hehehe. _________________ best regard,
tkk |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 11:15 am Post subject: |
|
|
| tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! |
Agree with u that comparisons should only be made within its specific classes as no 2 projects are alike even when proximate to each other, even from just across the road. Earlier i was just illustrating from Patrick's experience that projects could also go south for buyers, it's always good to get into something with your eyes wide open. Sometimes when we get into a buying frenzy we blindside ourselves to the obvious shortcomings or risks.
Btw i've heard time & again reference being made to Sri Manja as benchmarks for price appreciation for this project. I think that's flawed, as going by your same analogy that even within classes there're product & demographical differentiations. Sri Manja if u've noticed is predominantly chinese & its commercials there have thrived well, but if u were to drive further away into PJS u would notice the changing landscape of the area, the quality of businesses & tenants deteriorates & the demographics changes, with more indians & malays housed in council flats & low costs houses, which i also understand is the same landscape PA1120 is also situated in. This would eventually have a bearing on its caps as it'll be a key issue by which secondary buyers evaluate its desirability affecting its price.
But having said that, i've also purchased a property from a not so reputable developer in a not so desirable area & thru sheer luck have enjoyed great yields & price caps. It was a dsl link 18'x65' in Bandar Baru Ampang by Talam, purchased in the late 90s for just below 100k, leasehold. Tenant has been paying 850k per month & market value now is min 250k to 280k. Key difference is the area is largely chinese & near to KL.
Cheers! MERRY X'MAS to all!  |
Hi Daryl,
I'm fully agreed with you... dun forget you are getting the key soon for sierra residency puchong!!! the appreciation is quick alot also hehehe. |
Yeah thanks, was told should be Jan. The developer appointed agents, WCT Realtors, have already put up their signboard there citing 220k to 250k depending on flrs, layout & nos. of carparks! _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
tkk
Joined: 19 Sep 2006 Posts: 100 Location: PJ
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 11:21 am Post subject: |
|
|
Hi Daryl,
I'm fully agreed with you... dun forget you are getting the key soon for sierra residency puchong!!! the appreciation is quick alot also hehehe.[/quote]
Yeah thanks, was told should be Jan. The developer appointed agents, WCT Realtors, have already put up their signboard there citing 220k to 250k depending on flrs, layout & nos. of carparks![/quote]
-----------------------------------------------
Yes... mine is in 5th floor with 2 car parks... planning to sell 230k-240k.
all the best to you.... _________________ best regard,
tkk |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 11:26 am Post subject: |
|
|
| tkk wrote: | Hi Daryl,
I'm fully agreed with you... dun forget you are getting the key soon for sierra residency puchong!!! the appreciation is quick alot also hehehe. |
Yeah thanks, was told should be Jan. The developer appointed agents, WCT Realtors, have already put up their signboard there citing 220k to 250k depending on flrs, layout & nos. of carparks![/quote]
-----------------------------------------------
Yes... mine is in 5th floor with 2 car parks... planning to sell 230k-240k.
all the best to you....[/quote]
Mine are 3rd & 4th flr 907 sq ft with 1 open carpark. Looking at min 220k! Let's make it happen dude! _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 11:39 am Post subject: |
|
|
TKK, btw what's new in BJ & Sunway? I'd be interested.  _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
tkk
Joined: 19 Sep 2006 Posts: 100 Location: PJ
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:09 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Daryl Teo wrote: | TKK, btw what's new in BJ & Sunway? I'd be interested.  |
According from the breaking news... BJ(Freehold) will be launching in 2010-Q3 and Sunway(leasehold) is launching in 2010-Q2...
once i get more information i will probably open another thread for the discussion... the prices shall start from 260per sqf. The size is 12xx sqf onwards _________________ best regard,
tkk |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
cblee
Joined: 31 Oct 2005 Posts: 219
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:09 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Daryl Teo wrote: | | tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! |
Agree with u that comparisons should only be made within its specific classes as no 2 projects are alike even when proximate to each other, even from just across the road. Earlier i was just illustrating from Patrick's experience that projects could also go south for buyers, it's always good to get into something with your eyes wide open. Sometimes when we get into a buying frenzy we blindside ourselves to the obvious shortcomings or risks.
Btw i've heard time & again reference being made to Sri Manja as benchmarks for price appreciation for this project. I think that's flawed, as going by your same analogy that even within classes there're product & demographical differentiations. Sri Manja if u've noticed is predominantly chinese, with commercials that're thriving well there, but if u were to drive further away into PJS u would notice the changing landscape of the area, the quality of businesses & tenants deteriorates & the demographics changes, with more perceptibly lower income demographics of indians & malays housed in council flats & low costs houses, which i also understand is the same landscape PA1120 is also situated in. This would eventually have a bearing on its caps as it'll be a key issue by which secondary buyers evaluate its desirability affecting its price.
But having said that, i've also purchased a property from a not so reputable developer in a not so desirable area & thru sheer luck have enjoyed great yields & price caps. It was a dsl link 18'x65' in Bandar Baru Ampang by Talam, purchased in the late 90s for just below 100k, leasehold. Tenant has been paying 850k per month & market value now is min 250k to 280k. Key difference is the area is largely chinese & near to KL.
Cheers! MERRY X'MAS to all!  |
with the price level, 1120 is the star for the area and the location is good enuf to attract everybody. I believe chinese represent the biggest group of purchasers. Anyway, with 4 storey shops around, the project should not compared with the older condos around. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| cblee wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! |
Agree with u that comparisons should only be made within its specific classes as no 2 projects are alike even when proximate to each other, even from just across the road. Earlier i was just illustrating from Patrick's experience that projects could also go south for buyers, it's always good to get into something with your eyes wide open. Sometimes when we get into a buying frenzy we blindside ourselves to the obvious shortcomings or risks.
Btw i've heard time & again reference being made to Sri Manja as benchmarks for price appreciation for this project. I think that's flawed, as going by your same analogy that even within classes there're product & demographical differentiations. Sri Manja if u've noticed is predominantly chinese, with commercials that're thriving well there, but if u were to drive further away into PJS u would notice the changing landscape of the area, the quality of businesses & tenants deteriorates & the demographics changes, with more perceptibly lower income demographics of indians & malays housed in council flats & low costs houses, which i also understand is the same landscape PA1120 is also situated in. This would eventually have a bearing on its caps as it'll be a key issue by which secondary buyers evaluate its desirability affecting its price.
But having said that, i've also purchased a property from a not so reputable developer in a not so desirable area & thru sheer luck have enjoyed great yields & price caps. It was a dsl link 18'x65' in Bandar Baru Ampang by Talam, purchased in the late 90s for just below 100k, leasehold. Tenant has been paying 850k per month & market value now is min 250k to 280k. Key difference is the area is largely chinese & near to KL.
Cheers! MERRY X'MAS to all!  |
with the price level, 1120 is the star for the area and the location is good enuf to attract everybody. I believe chinese represent the biggest group of purchasers. Anyway, with 4 storey shops around, the project should not compared with the older condos around. |
Thanks & Good Luck! It's admirable what Peter is trying to achieve here. The area needs a bright shining star. Kudos! _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
tkk
Joined: 19 Sep 2006 Posts: 100 Location: PJ
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:16 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| cblee wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
Just got back from a stuffy dinner at Renaissance, the things we obliged ourselves sometimes to please our families!
Hey Patrick, thanks for representing the other view to tamp down all this buying euphoria fueled by imagined fantastic upsides & little or no reference to possible downsides! 1% caps p.a huh? Locational perception & its desirability, is 2nd to none, in prop investment, and this worst case scenario of property caps hitting the doldrums, will consistently repeat itself in urban ghettoes. Worst case, the prop may even depreciate. |
Hi,
we must compare to MPV to MPV and not MPV to Sedan !!!
i do a history checked in website. Pinang is just a apartment type and build in198x by Hong Leong and selling prices starting from 60k for first hand. furthermore no facilities and 1 car park given (not cover). and the location is in sentosa further in from OKR
if we want to compare MPV to MPV we could take a Sri Manja Court
Sri Manja Court come with all the facilities more or less same as 1120. build in 199x and selling prices is 90k for 1000sqf and now sub sales market is between 220k-240k
between, if you can take example for bukit jalil... why Vista CMV selling in auction 160k and sub-sales market only 200k for 1400sqf and why Covillea (450K-1200sqf) and Savanna(close to 400k-1200sqf) !!! is because of the new design, facilities, developer and management are totally different.
I'm accepting for 1120 all the pro/con from forum. Therefore i have invested over there. at the same time. i do invest for many others location also... all depends on whether you have enough $$$. as I'm putting less than 25k and wait to see 3 years time for the outcome... no matter how still better than i put in BANK FD (2%)....
by the way, my next investment 2010 is in Bukit Jalil & Sunway.... let's wait for the launching soon...
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year !!! |
Agree with u that comparisons should only be made within its specific classes as no 2 projects are alike even when proximate to each other, even from just across the road. Earlier i was just illustrating from Patrick's experience that projects could also go south for buyers, it's always good to get into something with your eyes wide open. Sometimes when we get into a buying frenzy we blindside ourselves to the obvious shortcomings or risks.
Btw i've heard time & again reference being made to Sri Manja as benchmarks for price appreciation for this project. I think that's flawed, as going by your same analogy that even within classes there're product & demographical differentiations. Sri Manja if u've noticed is predominantly chinese, with commercials that're thriving well there, but if u were to drive further away into PJS u would notice the changing landscape of the area, the quality of businesses & tenants deteriorates & the demographics changes, with more perceptibly lower income demographics of indians & malays housed in council flats & low costs houses, which i also understand is the same landscape PA1120 is also situated in. This would eventually have a bearing on its caps as it'll be a key issue by which secondary buyers evaluate its desirability affecting its price.
But having said that, i've also purchased a property from a not so reputable developer in a not so desirable area & thru sheer luck have enjoyed great yields & price caps. It was a dsl link 18'x65' in Bandar Baru Ampang by Talam, purchased in the late 90s for just below 100k, leasehold. Tenant has been paying 850k per month & market value now is min 250k to 280k. Key difference is the area is largely chinese & near to KL.
Cheers! MERRY X'MAS to all!  |
with the price level, 1120 is the star for the area and the location is good enuf to attract everybody. I believe chinese represent the biggest group of purchasers. Anyway, with 4 storey shops around, the project should not compared with the older condos around. |
fyi, Yesterday when signing the S&P i have asked question to 2nd Daughter. she told me 85% is Chinese purchaser and 15% are Malays and Indians. she also said that for 1120 do not have any quota for bumi, since PJS1 is belong to Peter's and overall is already over 30% quota for Bumi. Therefore the 2nd launching after CNY will sell like another hot cake... so far has more than 600++ registers
also, Peter is launching for the phase-2 shoplot just infront of 1120 next year in Q2
again... good luck to all the buyer... _________________ best regard,
tkk
Last edited by tkk on Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:19 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:17 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| tkk wrote: | | Daryl Teo wrote: | TKK, btw what's new in BJ & Sunway? I'd be interested.  |
According from the breaking news... BJ(Freehold) will be launching in 2010-Q3 and Sunway(leasehold) is launching in 2010-Q2...
once i get more information i will probably open another thread for the discussion... the prices shall start from 260per sqf. The size is 12xx sqf onwards |
Thanks TKK. Pls keep us posted. Cheers! _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Daryl Teo

Joined: 09 Feb 2008 Posts: 3755
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:37 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Btw i've also heard down the grapevine that further up where nearer to PJCC is, some developer was toying with the idea of building Grade A offices to tap the NPE. This was some years ago, whether idea will be brought to fruition or not, i've no idea whatsoever. I'm not condoning nor condemning purchases in this area. I, myself, am not vested here. So pls check your sources at your own peril.
Season's Greetings!  _________________ Buy land, they're not making it anymore.
Mark Twain |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
patricktoh187
Joined: 01 Aug 2009 Posts: 25 Location: Kuala Lumpur
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 12:53 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I have not seen anybody discuss about the maintenance fee. How much per sqf? One of the key factor that strata property could survive after VP is the maintenance fee collection.
Fyi most flats & apartments surronding this area had less than 50% paying rate. Imaging those people move into 1120PA. I hope I am wrong. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
king4891
Joined: 26 Aug 2009 Posts: 156
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 1:26 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| patricktoh187 wrote: | I have not seen anybody discuss about the maintenance fee. How much per sqf? One of the key factor that strata property could survive after VP is the maintenance fee collection.
Fyi most flats & apartments surronding this area had less than 50% paying rate. Imaging those people move into 1120PA. I hope I am wrong. |
100% sold within 1 week... Seem like nobody care about the maintenance cost. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
king4891
Joined: 26 Aug 2009 Posts: 156
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 2:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Daryl Teo wrote: | Btw i've also heard down the grapevine that further up where nearer to PJCC is, some developer was toying with the idea of building Grade A offices to tap the NPE. This was some years ago, whether idea will be brought to fruition or not, i've no idea whatsoever. I'm not condoning nor condemning purchases in this area. I, myself, am not vested here. So pls check your sources at your own peril.
Season's Greetings!  |
Sold out in 1 week. Seem like nobody care about the grapevine. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
flickr
Joined: 24 Apr 2007 Posts: 80
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 3:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Will all the dogs stop barking already?
Give it a bone already! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kewrien
Joined: 19 Dec 2009 Posts: 12
|
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 4:15 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| patricktoh187 wrote: | | king4891 wrote: | | patricktoh187 wrote: | Stay within 1km to 1120 project site since 10+ years ago but only got to know this project yesterday. Frankly speaking there is a lot of development in Sri Sentosa/PJS1 area in last 2-3 years. Personally I like this area very much but wifey has other thought.
Anyway I'll be moving out to Bukit Jalil next month. Good luck to all buyers.  |
Which condo or landed you bought at Bukit Jalil? |
I bought Savanna from sub-sale market. It is about 1200 sqf & comes with 1+2 car parks.
I sold off current staying Pinang 1A apartment (2nd floor 920sqf) for RM127k which I bought 3rd hand at RM115k 10 years ago. You will notice the propety value only appreciate ~1% pa.  |
10 years? you're too young for that area. i have been there for 20 years. 2 main reason why it appreciate ~1% p
1st - it was not worth that price but people still buy it.
2nd - 3rd hand house have very less potential to get earned already.
besides, check the appreciation with other courts such as manja court, avant court, sentosa court and many more nearby there? friendly reminder, do not count 1st hand sell to 2nd hand, NOT 2nd hand sell to 3rd hand.
ps: do not often listen to wife. do own judgement like a real man. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|

This is a free forum intended to foster communication between
all users.
Hileytech Sdn Bhd does not guarantee the correctness or validity of postings,
nor does Hileytech endorse any postings. No posting or contents in this forum
can be copied and reproduced without prior permission from Hileytech and the
owner of the posting. All other names and marks are trade names, trademarks or
registered trademarks of their respective owners.
Powered by phpBB,
Another web site by www.hileytech.com,Forum Archive
Tel : +60-3-42978281 :: Fax : +60-3-42978254 :: hiley@hileytech.com
|